The Staples & Covells Wreck at New Era - 1894

Editor's Note: This is a graphic description of the accident. Readers are advised.

From the Detroit Free Press, April 10, 1894.

Muskegon, April 9. (Special) - Engineer Adolph Shetlander, 45, leaves a widow and two children; Fireman Gust Anderson, 30, single; Foreman Frank Shippy, 25, leaves a widow and daughter; Trainmen Martin Lynch, married; Charles Wolf, Loren and Allen Critchett, all single, are dead, and Fred Chawkee and Henry Stearn, both single, badly injured

The above is the result of a horrible accident this morning on the logging railroad of Staples & Covell in Oceana County, near New Era.

Chawkee, who was so severally injured, received his injuries in attempting to aid a fellow workman. He will probably die. Stearn saved his life by jumping through a window. The men were on their way to dinner. The accident occurred shortly before noon, while the engine, containing nine men, was on its way from White river to the camp, six miles distant. The day was cold and rainy.

Within 100 rods of camp, a tree blew upon the track in front of the engine, which, when it jumped into the air, straddled the track, tottered a moment, and then tumbled end over end and down a 16-foot embankment, where is now lies, bottom side up. The escaping steam and red hot coals did their deadly work rapidly.

Loren and Allen Critchett, who made their escape with scalps burned off, blood-covered faces and mangled limbs, ran up the track to camp and gave the alarm nearer dead than alive. Anderson, the fireman, crawled away for 50 feet and died in awful agony. Martin Lynch walked unaided a mile, and explained: "Boys, I'm going to die, send for the priest and pray for me," and then died.

All of the bodies are laid out on the floor of the camps in charge of Undertaken Moog of Whitehall. The coroner at Shelby has been sent for. All the men were strong and healthy men and respected. The road runs from three miles east of New Era to White river. It has been in operation for over five years, and would have finished logging Wednesday for good, and then have been moved to other parts.

Engineer Shetland has been in charge ever since the road was started, and this is his first accident. He was to have taken another position in a week. All of the men live in Whitehall except those designated. They boarded at the camps and went home once a month to visit. They were home Monday and returned Tuesday morning.

When the news was received at Whitehall, Staples & Covell hired rigs and drove the families of the injured men to the scene, which was a most heartrending one. The company is doing everything possible for the dead and the dying and for the families. The surrounding towns are wild with excitement and grief. The engine cab was enclosed from the storm and the windows were the only means of escape.

Frank Shippy had his stomach burned out with coals from the furnace. He saw the tree fall, but there was no time to stop the engine after he gave the alarm. Both Critchetts died in great agony. They were found with their fingers burned off and flesh peeling from their bodies. [DFP-1894-0410]


Further information: When the train struck the tree, the engine was thrown from the rails and went rolling down an embankment, taking with it a number of logging cars, which all piled upon it. It was a terrible scene. The whole crew went with it. They were pinned down by the logging cars and crushed to death. To add to the awful sufferings, the imprisoned men were scalded by escaping steam. 

The bodies were taken to Whitehall, where most of the men resided. All Whitehall is in mourning today over the awful tragedy. Fred Chawker is yet alive but is expected to die at almost any moment. The bodies of the seven victims are embalmed and their faces present but little trace of their fiery ordeal. [DFP-1894-0411]


A Ballad Was Written About the Wreck
 

[Verse 1]

In eighteen-ninety-four, at dawn’s cold April glow,

A storm had swept through Oceana’s woods, where mighty east winds blow.

Nine men rode out on a logging run, near New Era’s lonesome track,

A short train hauling timber, no cars, just logs stacked back.

Engineer Moore at the throttle, with fireman stoking the flame, Seven more worked the Staples line, bound for a fateful claim.

[Verse 2] The rails curved through the misty pines, where a great tree blocked the way,

Felled by the storm’s fierce bluster, in the dim of early day.

The engine roared in reverse, blind to the limbs ahead,

A curve and grade hid the danger, where the fallen oak was spread.

They struck it fast, the iron rolled, down the grade the engine fell,

The steam pipe burst with a scalding roar, unleashing fiery hell.

[Verse 3] The wreck lay tangled in the mud, logs scattered o’er the ground,

Nine men burned by the boiler’s breath, no mercy to be found.

No doctor’s hand in that wild wood could ease their tortured cries,

The camp too far, their wounds too deep, beneath those graying skies.

Some lingered long in agony, one chose a quicker flight,

In Shelby’s shade, their lives were lost, to pain’s unyielding bite.

[Chorus] Oh, the steam it screams like a mourner’s wail, in the wreck of the Staples line,

Scalded flesh and broken hearts, where dawn’s faint rays don’t shine.

No hope in the healer’s art back then, just torment without end,

None could blame their desperate hearts for seeking a swifter end.

[Bridge] The tracks now fade where the great tree fell, but whispers haunt the dawn,

Of nine who faced a scalding hell, and only two lived on.

Sing low for the crew of the Staples run, who braved the lumber’s call,

Their tale endures in the wind and sun, where Michigan’s pines stand tall.

[Spoken outro] This ballad tells the true story of a tragedy that struck on April 9, 1894, in Oceana County, Michigan, near New Era. The Staples and Covell logging train, hauling logs on a lonesome track, met its doom when it hit a storm-felled tree. The tree’s branches tore into the engine, and hot embers from the firebox rained on the crew, adding burns to their scalded wounds. Six of the nine men died slow, agonizing deaths. One man, Martin Lynch, staggered nearly a mile before he fell. Two survived, forever scarred. Let’s pause to honor those men—and keep their memories alive.

[Chorus] Oh, the steam it screams like a mourner’s wail, in the wreck of the Staples line,

Scalded flesh and broken hearts, where dawn’s faint rays don’t shine.

No hope in the healer’s art back then, just torment without end,

None could blame their desperate hearts for seeking a swifter end.


To play the ballad on Suno.com, click here.

Bibliography

The following sources are utilized in this website. [SOURCE-YEAR-MMDD-PG]:

  • [AAB| = All Aboard!, by Willis Dunbar, Eerdmans Publishing, Grand Rapids ©1969.
  • [AAN] = Alpena Argus newspaper.
  • [AARQJ] = American Association of Railroads Quiz Jr. pamphlet. © 1956
  • [AATHA] = Ann Arbor Railroad Technical and Historical Association newsletter "The Double A"
  • [AB] = Information provided at Michigan History Conference from Andrew Bailey, Port Huron, MI

Contact Us

Invalid Input

Invalid Input

Invalid Input

Invalid Input

Invalid Input

Invalid Input

 
Email: webmaster@michiganrailroads.com

Social